HOME / Senza categoria
Senza categoria

WHIPLASH — Directed by Damien Chazelle

March 9, 2015 / arenatoppeghen
ARENA TOPPEGHEN / READINGSenza categoria

Whiplash-poster

 

PLOT: Nineteen-year-old Andrew dreams of becoming one of the finest jazz drummers of his generation. But competition is fierce at the Manhattan conservatoire, where he practises relentlessly. He is also determined to earn a place in one of the conservatoire’s ensembles, led by the uncompromising and ferocious teacher Terence Fletcher. When he finally succeeds, Andrew throws himself into the pursuit of excellence under Fletcher’s guidance.

Here’s the trailer:

After a lot of hesitation I finally managed to watch this film, which, in my view, had undeservedly been included among the contenders for the Best Picture Oscar.
Overall, the film only just scrapes a pass, and much of that assessment is influenced by J. K. Simmons’s tremendous performance. He deservedly won the Oscar for Best Supporting Actor, beating Edward Norton for Birdman — whom, until yesterday, I considered the number-one unjustly defeated contender. Having now watched the monstrous music teacher Terence Fletcher, I can see why. Simmons outdoes himself, alternating between kindness and cruelty and leaving the viewer unsure of his true nature and what he really thinks of the young drummer Andrew Neiman (played by Miles Teller).
In the end, I find both the story and direction lacking, making the film tedious and repetitive. It takes place almost entirely on stage and in the rehearsal room, without developing either the father–son relationship or the drummer’s romance. I think it’s far too easy to justify this by claiming that Andrew’s obsessive dedication has wiped out every human relationship except the one with his teacher.
The editing, on the other hand, is distinctive. At times you can recognise the style of a music video, with exceptional cuts perfectly timed to the music (although the Oscar in this category did seem a little excessive to me).
Another striking choice is the portrayal of Andrew as a ruthless bastard who has no qualms about pushing aside first Connelly and then Tanner, the established drummers in the two ensembles he plays with. His acting performance, however, leaves something to be desired.
The decision to show so much blood on the drumheads is also rather questionable…
The music is excellent, particularly the piece Whiplash, which gives the film its title.
RATING: 6
ilo

WHERE TO WATCH

Loading availability…

Availability data: JustWatch via TMDB. TMDB · JustWatch

Leave a Reply